Maas' route to the Seres.
The ' Valley of the
Position of the ' Stone Tower.'
64 HISTORICAL NOTICES OF KASHGAR [Chap. III
According to Ptolemy's express statement, Marinus gathered his geographical data about the land of the Seres from the account given by Maës, a Macedonian merchant ' called also Titianus ', who had sent agents into the country. The route of these agents, which we may safely assume to have been a caravan road in frequent use for the silk-trade from China into the Parthian Empire, led from Hierapolis on the Euphrates through Hekatompylos, Areia, and Margiana (Merv) to Baktra. From there the route passed first northward to the mountain district of the Komedi, and then along it to the south-east ' as far as the ravine that opens into the plain country '. In this ravine the traveller had to ascend for 5o schoeni northward when ' he arrives at the Stone Tower, after which the mountains recede to the east and unite with Imaus, the range that runs up to the north from Palimbothra'.12 Another passage of Ptolemy places to the east of the Stone Tower, and in the axis of Mount Imaus itself, the station or Sarai (ôpµijTljpwov) whence traders start on their journey to Sera '.13
It is the joint merit of Sir H. Yule and Sir H. Rawlinson to have demonstrated beyond all doubt the identity of the mountain tract of the Komedi with the Chü-mi-t`o of Hsüan-tsang on the one hand and the 'land of the Kumédh' of early Muhammadan writers on the other". It thus became possible to locate with certainty ' the valley of the Komedi ' in the mountains which divide the Wakhshâb river and the adjacent alpine tracts of Karategin from the course of the Oxus. From Karategin a direct and comparatively easy line of communication leads along the Wakhshab up to the rich grazing grounds of the wide Alai plateau. Ascending the latter to its eastern end, it then crosses the watershed range between the Oxus and the Tarim at its lowest point, the Taun-murun Pass 16 ; and a short distance below, near the headwaters of the Kashgar river, it joins the great route which connects Kashgar with Farghana over the Terek Dawân.
Baron Richthofen, by a series of convincing arguments, has proved how closely the description of the road followed by Maës' agents agrees with the route just indicated 16. An exact location of the famous ' Stone Tower ' (X(etvos irvpyos) is not possible at present, and can be hoped for only from antiquarian investigations effected on the spot 17. In regard, however, to the
" See Ptolemy, Geographia, I. cap. xii. 7 sqq. By Imaus is meant the watershed range between the Oxus and the Tarim ; compare Richthofen, China, i. p. 484.
'$ Ptolemy, Geogr. VI. cap. xiii. r. It deserves to be noted that the traders' station is placed due east of the Stone Tower ', Lat. 43° being indicated for both.
" See Yule, in J.R.A.S., 1873, pp. 97 sq. ; for other references compare Richthofen, China, L p. 497, note. The connexion between the Komedi of Ptolemy and Chef-mi-fo of Hsüan-tsang had first suggested itself to SirA. Cunningham; but as in the case of numerous other conjectural identifications, which in the end proved equally happy, he was not able to support it by critical evidence or to locate the territory. On the other hand, the discussion of the Ptolemy passage in Cathay, i. p. cxlix, is still of value, as showing how Sir H. Yule, by a chain of sound critical reasoning, had been led to Karategin as the probable position of the Komedi, even before information became available as to the survival of the local name into Muhammadan times.
" This is the form in which I heard the name pronounced on the spot ; General Kuropatkin writes ' Toongoobooroon,' see Kashgaria, translated by Major W. E. Gowan (Calcutta, î882), p. 31. In the Russian Survey Maps the
spelling Taun-murun seems to have been adopted.
'e See China, i. pp. 496 sqq.
17 The question as to the position of the ' Stone Tower' had been discussed at length by a number of distinguished scholars, from Humboldt to Sir H. Rawlinson, before the identification of the mountains of the Komedi supplied a definite clue to the direction of Maës' route. For a synopsis of these conjectured locations, which range from Tâshkend in the north-west to Tash-kurghân in the south-east, see Richthofen, China, i. p. 498, and McCrindle, Ancient India as described by Ptolemy (Bombay, 1885), p. 12.
I avail mysélf of this opportunity to correct the error into which I fell by accepting Sir H. Rawlinson's identification of the altcvos irvpyos with Tash-kurghân, in my Preliminary Report, p. 12, and also in Ruins of Khotan, p. 71. When writing the original diary notes on which both the above records of my journey are based, my scope for reference on the subject was restricted to Dr. McCrindle's above-quoted publication on Ptolemy, in the copious notes of which the well-established identification of the Komedi has unfortunately remained unnoticed.
The more recent conjectures concerning the position of the Stone Tower,' which Dr. Marquart quotes in his Érânlahr,