National Institute of Informatics - Digital Silk Road Project
Digital Archive of Toyo Bunko Rare Books

> > > >
Color New!IIIF Color HighRes Gray HighRes PDF   Japanese English
0230 Southern Tibet : vol.3
Southern Tibet : vol.3 / Page 230 (Color Image)

New!Citation Information

doi: 10.20676/00000263
Citation Format: Chicago | APA | Harvard | IEEE

OCR Text

of the Kara-korum peaks he regards as somewhat lower than those of the Hima-
laya, but the average height of ridges and passes is higher.

In spite of Nain Sing's journey he has not changed his view regarding Tibet,
a fact that indicates that the Pundit's journey was not sufficient for suspecting the
existence of a range between the Kara-korum and the Tsangpo. Thus Tibet re-
mains simply a latitudinal valley bordered by the Dihong and the Indus and by
Himalaya and Kara-korum. Kwen-lun is outside of Tibet, and between Kara-korum
and Kwen-lun is a plateau with irregular distribution of mountains and valleys.

After having expressed his views regarding the sources of the Dihong, as he
calls even the Tsangpo, he continues:¹

»Die Himálayakammlinie ist hier ungeachtet ihrer bedeutenden Höhe dem Hauptthale
sehr nahe liegend; auf der linken, der Karakorümseite aber muss die wasserscheidende Linie
sehr ferne noch liegen; vor der Hauptkette erhebt sich hier noch die Kette des Chomoráng-
Gebirges. Der grösste Theil der Chomorang-Kette gehört zu Gnári Khôrsum. Sie beginnt im
Westen in der Provinz von Pangkong. Als mächtige Kette trat das Chomorang-Gebirge sehr
deutlich in den Umgebungen von Gártok hervor; es ist auch als Mittelkette von Gnari Khorsum
mit seiner etwas isolirt stehenden Fortsetzung in Ost-Tibet auf unserer Routen-Karte von 1861
angebracht. Der Name wurde erst durch die Pundits bekannt.»

Even here, in a work published seven years after Nain Sing's journey along
the Tsangpo, Schlagintweit speaks of the left, Kara-korum-side of the main valley.
He knows Hodgson's works for he quotes him elsewhere. But he has nothing to
say of his Nien-chen-tang-la. And still we easily find on his map of 1861² an un-
mistakable revival, at least partly, of Hodgson's range. The Kara-korum range
runs diagonally through the whole interior of Tibet. From the Kara-korum pass
it runs S.E., south of the Ike Namur-nor, which is, by the way, represented as the
source of Keriya-darya, an invention made entirely by Schlagintweit himself, for there
is nothing in the original Chinese map, that justifies such an arrangement. But he
is no doubt right in drawing the northern Kara-korum south-eastwards. But how
could he know? Nobody had ever been there. It is only conjecture that happens
to be right.

Then, suddenly the system turns to the east, S.E., south and finally east again.
From where has he got this sharp bend, and how can he know that a part of the
Kara-korum, in the very unknown heart of Tibet, is meridional? In the eastern part
of the range, which runs west and east, we recognize a bastard between the maps
of d'Anville and Hodgson. Or rather, the rivers are d'Anville's, the range Hodg-
son's. From this we also understand why Schlagintweit has nothing to say of the
Transhimalaya. For he makes the Kara-korum turn southwards and run between
the Tengri-nor and the Tsangpo. He suspects two systems, but he combines them.