国立情報学研究所 - ディジタル・シルクロード・プロジェクト
『東洋文庫所蔵』貴重書デジタルアーカイブ

> > > >
カラー New!IIIFカラー高解像度 白黒高解像度 PDF   日本語 English
0321 Explorations in Turkestan : Expedition of 1904 : vol.1
トルキスタンの調査 1904年 : vol.1
Explorations in Turkestan : Expedition of 1904 : vol.1 / 321 ページ(カラー画像)

New!引用情報

doi: 10.20676/00000178
引用形式選択: Chicago | APA | Harvard | IEEE

OCR読み取り結果

 

CONCLUDING REMARKS.   181 •

Sellin leaves it an open question whether or not we have here in Ta'aneek evidence of the sacrifice of children buried alive, such as was observed under the Canaanitic temple in Gezer (Palestine Exploration Fund, 1903, pp. 32 ff.).

Naturally we are still less able in the case of Transcaspia than in that of Ta'aneek to draw any conclusions as to whether such ideas underlie the method of child burials. The graves at Anau are certainly different, not only in the position of the skeletons, but also in the frequently greater age of the children buried in them. Here we certainly have no evidence of sacrifices. The future may throw more light on the burial custom of Anau.

In connection with the lapis-lazuli button drilled with an elbow-shaped hole (fig. 338) we may remark that similar buttons were widely distributed in Europe in the period of transition from stone to metal (cf. M. Much, die Kupferzeit in Europa, 2d edition, p. 95 ff.; Olshausen, Zeitschrift für Ethnologie, 189o, Verhandlungen, p. 287 ff.). What connection may have existed between these widely separated occurrences is uncertain.*

Mention has frequently been made of flint implements and flint flakes. Obsidian is a great rarity. It is represented in a single well-worked arrow-point (fig. 386) in culture III. There probably it was imported, either ready-made or in the raw material. The nearest source would probably be in the Caucasus.

Among the objects made from metal—copper or bronze—there occur few which invite comparison with other fields of discovery. The ornamental pins of culture I represent the simplest types that remained in use in Europe from the earliest metal times up to the iron age and they have a wide range of distribution (cf. figs. 238 and 240). In Anau, too, these types continue through culture II into culture III. As parallels I mention only those from Troja-Hissarlik, whose stock of types connects Asia Minor with Europe over the bridge of the lEgean Sea. Thus the pin with a round cross-section and double pyramidal head (fig. 239) dccurs also in the Schliemann collection under the catalogue number 6292 (Doerpfeld, Troja and Ilion, p. 355, fig. 29oc) ; and the pins with four-edged cross-section (figs. 238 and 244) will be found in catalogue numbers 6336 and 6353 (= Troja and Ilion, figs. 219a and 291c). Special remark attaches to the scroll pins (Rollennadeln). The type with a single scroll, so widely distributed in Europe (cf. R. Virchow, das Graeberfeld von Koban, pp. 32 ff.), is wanting among our finds. A corresponding form of head is seen on the tweezers from culture III (fig. 269). On the other hand, the pin with double scroll is represented by two specimens in culture III (figs. 251 and 252). In a general survey of the distribution of this type one would have to distinguish between those with wire spirals (Drahtspiralen) (e. g., in M. Much, Kunsthistor, Atlas, plate xxir, 5, and p. 62, fig. 18; or, Montelius, Civilisation primitive en Italie, 1, plates 7, 5, 16, 20, from Italian pile-dwellings and terramara) and those with band-spirals (bandspiralen). The latter were found in Anau. Their nearest parallels would again be Trojan (Cat. No. 64o1, 6402 =Troja and Ilion, figs. 294h and 294i).

*As this button came from + 2 to +3 feet in the "mixed strata" of the outer digging of the South Kurgan it may have belonged to culture III.—R. P.